1. Directory of nonprofits
  2. Locations
  3. Indiana
  4. Indiana insurance companies

Indiana insurance companies

There are 35 insurance providers in Indiana. Combined, these Hoosier insurance companies employ 78 people, earn more than $123 million in revenue each year, and have assets of $591 million.
Skip to:
Related directory pages:

Insurance companies by major Indiana cities

Metro areaNonprofitsRevenues
Indianapolis
 
13
 
$85,547,296
Fort Wayne
 
3
 
$0
Terre Haute
 
2
 
$0
Elkhart
 
2
 
$4,102,349
Columbus, IN
 
2
 
$627,714
South Bend
 
1
 
$29,753,708
Evansville
 
1
 
$6,417
Chicago, IL
 
1
 
$0
Bloomington, IN
 
1
 
$99,479
Showing 9 of 9 metros

Job trends for Indiana insurance companies

Employees per organizationNumber of organizations
0
 
12
1-10
 
10
11-25
 
1
26-100
 
1
101 to 1,000
 
0
1,000+
 
0
Key takeaways for employment stats:

Sizes of insurance companies in Indiana

Revenues per organizationNumber of organizations
< $250k
 
5
$250k to $1M
 
11
$1M to $5M
 
6
$5M to $25M
 
3
$25M to $100M
 
2
$100M+
 
0
Key takeaways for revenue stats:

Directory of insurance companies in Indiana

Want to add filters to this list, or drill down on results in detail? Open in the Cause IQ search interface
1-20 of 35

Indiana Compensation Rating Bureau

The Indiana Compensation Rating Bureau is a not-for-profit organization that regulates worker compensation rates in the state of Indiana.
Revenue
$2.7m
Assets
$2.3m
Employees
9
EIN
35-0837318
IRS type
501(c)(6)

Indiana Insurance Guaranty Association (IIGA)

The IIGA is the property and casualty insurance guaranty association for the State of Indiana. The association is composed of most insurance companies licensed to sell property and casualty insurance in Indiana.
Revenue
$4.9m
Assets
$9.5m
Employees
0
EIN
23-7211200
IRS type
501(c)(6)

Police and Firemens Insurance Association

Provides scholarships, insurance and investment programs to police and fire personnel and their families. Includes orphans assistance and family fraternal benefits.
Revenue
$48.3m
Assets
$284.0m
Employees
32
EIN
35-0586820
IRS type
501(c)(8)

Indiana Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Association

The Indiana Life and Health Insurance Guaranty Association was established to provide certain protections to policyholders of insolvent insurance companies in accordance with India code 27-8-8.
Revenue
$2.2m
Assets
$8.6m
Employees
0
EIN
35-1444018
IRS type
501(c)(6)

Lions Insurance Company

To provide Insurance covering the professional (malpractice) and general liability exposures of the nursing homes operated by health and hospital corporation of marion county (hhc); to provide tail coverage relating to potential exposure for professional ....
Revenue
$7.2m
Assets
$36.4m
Employees
0
EIN
20-4372643
IRS type
501(c)(3)

Hills Insurance Company

Hills provides self-insurance to hospitals owned by Franciscan Alliance, and is a captive insurer issuing policies of professional and general liability.
Revenue
$29.8m
Assets
$209.9m
Employees
0
EIN
03-0372512
IRS type
501(c)(3)

Small Business Aid

Small Business Aid, Inc facilitates a voluntary mutual aid plan exclusive to Amish employers and business owners who share the burden of work place accidents or other specified losses. The plan does not include illnesses and is located in Shipshewana, IN.
Revenue
$3.4m
Assets
$1.4m
Employees
3
EIN
27-1353904
IRS type
501(c)(3)

Anthem Supplemental Unemployment Benefit Trust

Anthem Trust offers welfare plan to provide Supplemental Unemployment Pay to eligible associates of Elevance Health, Inc and affiliates in Indianapolis.
Revenue
$5.6m
Assets
$103.6k
Employees
0
EIN
82-6729294
IRS type
501(c)(17)

Woodlawn Medical Aid

Woodlawn Medical Aid offers reimbursement for medical expenses to members of Woodlawn Amish Mennonite Church and other similar Amish Mennonite congregations.
Revenue
$1.1m
Assets
$818.7k
Employees
0
EIN
46-5256429
IRS type
501(c)(3)

Eli Lilly and Company Master Trust for Employee Benefits

VEBA trust providing funding for medical and dental benefits to eligible employees of Eli Lilly & Co. in Indianapolis, IN.
Revenue
$10.4m
Assets
$13.1m
Employees
0
EIN
35-1589453
IRS type
501(c)(9)

Mennonite Motorist Aid of Indiana

Mennonite Motorist Aid of Indiana is a non-profit, faith-based organization that provides auto insurance at cost to Mennonite church members only - who are both the insurers and the insured. The organization is located in Nappanee, IN.
Revenue
$751.1k
Assets
$367.8k
Employees
0
EIN
35-1968611
IRS type
501(c)(15)

Morgan County Group Insurance Trust

Reimbursement of covered health care expenses incurred by members and their eligible dependents, less reimbursements received from health care providers and from excess-loss insurance. Premiums paid for excess-loss insurance. Premiums paid for members' group term life insurance.
Revenue
$2.6m
Assets
$799.7k
Employees
0
EIN
35-6522773
IRS type
501(c)(9)

The Farmers Home Insurance Company of Knox County

The Farmers Home Insurance Company of Knox County is an insurance provider in Vincennes, IN that was founded in 1988.
Revenue
N/A
Assets
N/A
Employees
N/A
EIN
35-0303067
IRS type
501(c)(15)

Farmers Mutual Fire and Aid Association of Laugherty Township

To provide low cost fire and aid insurance to it's members. To provide low cost fire & aid insurance to it's members.
Revenue
N/A
Assets
N/A
Employees
N/A
EIN
62-1124551
IRS type
501(c)(15)

Farmers Mutual Rescue Insurance of Lagrange

Farmers Mutual Rescue Insurance of Lagrange provides insurance to Lagrange County, Indiana and surrounding areas through a mutual insurance company. The company's programs cover expenses incurred to provide insurance policies to members.
Revenue
$336.0k
Assets
$3.6m
Employees
1
EIN
35-1081842
IRS type
501(c)(15)

Widner Mutual Fire Ins Association

The Widner Mutual Fire Ins Association operates as a 501(c)(15) mutual insurance company, offering affordable fire and wind insurance coverage for the local community of Freelandville, Indiana.
Revenue
$437.6k
Assets
$4.1m
Employees
6
EIN
35-1066427
IRS type
501(c)(15)

St Joseph Mutual Home Ins Fuldast Meinrad

St Joseph Mutual Home Ins Fuldast Meinrad is an insurance provider in Saint Meinrad, IN whose mission is: Mutual farm insurance sales.
Revenue
$575.6k
Assets
$2.1m
Employees
0
EIN
31-1008142
IRS type
501(c)(15)

First Farm Mutual Insurance Company

First Farm Mutual Insurance Company is a mutual insurance company located in Seymour, Indiana. The Company operates in four counties in south central Indiana and insures its members' property, including Farm buildings, furniture, homes and mobile hom...
Revenue
$297.5k
Assets
$899.5k
Employees
3
EIN
35-0988187
IRS type
501(c)(15)

St Celestine Mutual Fire Ins

St Celestine Mutual Fire Ins is an insurance provider in Jasper, IN whose mission is: The sole activity of the exempt organization is the operation of a Mutual Fire insurance company.
Revenue
$115.7k
Assets
$979.2k
Employees
1
EIN
35-1409936
IRS type
501(c)(15)

Travelers Protective Association of America / Indiana Division A Post

Travelers Protective Association of America / Indiana Division A Post is an insurance provider in Fort Wayne, IN that was founded in 1941.
Revenue
N/A
Assets
N/A
Employees
N/A
EIN
35-6033346
IRS type
501(c)(8)
Want more insights on insurance companies in Indiana?
There's a whole lot more to Cause IQ than what you see here. Additional filters, personnel information, peer benchmarking, Salesforce integration, vendor lists, etc. Access all the information your company needs in one place, already collected.
Schedule a demo
Over 200 customers use Cause IQ to grow, maintain, and serve their nonprofit clients.
Methodology: Cause IQ mines all tax-exempt organizations that file a Form 990, Form 990-EZ, or Form 990-PF with the IRS. We collect and aggregate this information from OCR'd paper taxreturns, XML e-file taxreturns, IRS-provided extract, the Business Master File, and Cause IQ secret sauce for data cleaning, categorization, classification, analytics, etc.
This category corresponds to the "Y20: Insurance Providers, Services" National Taxonomy of Exempt Entities (NTEE) code. Cause IQ determines NTEEs for organizations by its own internally-developed secret-sauce algorithms.
Cause IQ is a website that helps companies grow, maintain, and serve their nonprofit clients, and helps nonprofits find additional foundation funding. Our data and tools help professionals prospect for nonprofits, research opportunities, benchmark their clients, and enrich existing information.
Nonprofits
Product
Customers
About

© 2026 Nonprofit Metrics LLC
Terms of Service and Privacy Policy